Wednesday, September 4, 2013

continued discussion from class

I began reading up more on the actual cause of death of Virginia Woolf. It was to say a little bit macabre then just walking into a lake in drowning. It was said she suffered from a 'manic-depressive illness'.  But as I was reading I found she left a final note to her husband who was said to have supported her tremendously. So, I found out she was married and it goes on to say interestingly that in two books by Stephen Trombley that "Woolf is described as having a confrontational relationship with her doctors, and possibly being a woman who is a "victim of male medicine", referring to the contemporary relative lack of understanding about mental illness". I found this interesting that even her mental health was affected by her being a woman trying to be treated by a male doctor. Which makes me wonder, what if it was a female doctor; what if that was a commonality at the time? Is it possible her mental illness could have been more understood? 

2 comments:

  1. I honestly don't think it would've been any different had it been a female doctor versus a male doctor. Mental illness was not very treatable at the time, regardless of the gender of the care-giver.

    Manic-depressive illnesses--like bipolar disorder--could also explain her confrontational demeanor (mania can cause extreme irritation).

    Mental illness is like any other sickness. It's not a novelty item--like a t-shirt that says "Kiss me, I'm depressed!" Even though her husband was very supportive, an illness is still an illness, and mental illnesses cannot be cured with love alone.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm aware of this. It's just really hard to think of gender related issues such as that when you're really thinking scientifically. Really, I don't care who the doctor was or what gender they were. You're right, there wasn't any real treatment then. Mania sends the person into a well, manic and they talk fast express their ideas fast in their head and out loud just never slowing down. So, you're right love alone couldn't cure a mood disorder.

    ReplyDelete